17 August
2009
PRESS RELEASE
Palestinian
Public Opinion Poll No (33)
While the
popularity of Abbas and Fateh increases and the popularity of Ismail Haniyeh
and Hamas decreases, and while perception of personal and family security and
safety increases and perception of corruption in PA institutions decreases, the
public remains pessimistic about the future of reconciliation and shows total
lack of confidence in the ability of elections to restore the unity of the West
Bank and the Gaza Strip
13-15 August 2009
These are the results of the latest poll conducted
by the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research (PSR) in the West Bank
and the Gaza Strip between 13 and 15 August 2009. The poll was conducted in the
aftermath of the holding of Fateh’s Sixth Congress in Bethlehem and Hamas’s
refusal to allow Fateh members to leave the Gaza Strip to participate in the
Congress. Total size of the sample is 1270 adults interviewed face to face in
127 randomly selected locations. Margin of error is 3%. This press release
covers domestic Palestinian issues; issues related to the peace process and
Israeli-Palestinian relations will be covered in a separate joint
Palestinian-Israeli press release. For further details, contact PSR director,
Dr. Khalil Shikaki, or Walid Ladadweh at tel 02-296
4933 or email pcpsr@pcpsr.org.
Main Findings:
Findings of the
third quarter of 2009 show an increase in the popularity of Fateh and president
Mahmud Abbas and a decline in the popularity of Hamas and Ismail Haniyeh, the
dismissed prime minister. The rise in the popularity of Fateh and Abbas might
in part be the result of Fateh’s success in holding its long awaited Sixth
Congress and electing a new leadership. The decline in support for Hamas might
in part be the result of its refusal to allow Fateh members in the Gaza Strip
to travel to Bethlehem to participate in Fateh’s Sixth Congress. Findings show
additional and perhaps deeper reasons for the change in the balance of power
between Fateh and Hamas. For example, they show considerable improvement in
public perception of personal and family security and safety in the West Bank
and a noticeable decrease in the public perception of the existence of
corruption in PA institutions under Abbas and Prime Minister Salam Fayyad. In this context, findings show some optimism
about the future of Fateh in the aftermath of its Sixth Congress and about the
ability of its newly elected leadership to fight corruption inside the movement
and to deliver reconciliation with Hamas. But the public does not believe that
the new leadership will be different from the previous one in its ability to
work to end the Israeli occupation.
Findings also show
public confusion regarding new presidential and parliamentary elections. A
majority believes that reconciliation talks between Fateh and Hamas will fail.
A majority also believes that PA president and parliament will lose their
legitimacy next January when their terms end. Nonetheless, a wide majority opposes
postponing the elections and a majority also opposes holding elections under
the current status quo, with Haniyeh’s government supervising it in the Gaza
Strip and Fayyad’s government supervising it in the West Bank, even if they
were organized by a single unified election commission. Moreover, an
overwhelming majority opposes holding separate elections in either the Gaza
Strip, organized by the Haniyeh government, or in the
West Bank, organized by the Fayyad government. In any case, findings show that
the public has no confidence in the ability of the legislative and presidential
elections to contribute to the re-unification of the West Bank and the Gaza
Strip. An overwhelming majority believes that the two sides, Fateh and Hamas,
or one of them, will reject the results of any new fair and free elections if
those results were not in its favor.
Finally, despite the
improvement in the perception of personal and family security and safety,
particularly in the West Bank, a majority of those who have been attacked or
robbed during the past year says they have not complained to the police either
because they do not trust it or because it can do nothing useful for them.
Worse yet, the overwhelming majority of those who did submit a complaint to the
police says they are not satisfied with the police performance. Findings show
that lack of trust with the police increases in the Gaza Strip compared to the
West Bank, but dissatisfaction with the performance of the police is similar to
that in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.
- Increase in the percentage of those who would
vote for Mahmud Abbas as president of the PA from 49% three months ago to
52% in this poll and a decrease in the vote for Ismail Haniyeh from 44% to
38%. 9% remain undecided in this poll and only 60% say they would
participate in those elections. However, if the competition was between
Marwan Barghouti and Ismail Haniyeh, the former would receive 62% of the
vote and the latter 31%. 7% remain undecided and rate of participation
increases to 71%.
- Increase in the percentage of those who would
vote for Fateh from 41% three months ago to 44% in this poll and a
decrease in the percentage of those who would vote for Hamas from 33% to
28% during the same period. Vote for all other electoral lists reaches 11%
and 17% remain undecided. Rate of election participation stands at 68%.
- Most popular figures selected by the public as
possible vice president are Marwan Barghouti (selected by 37% of the
public), Ismail Haniyeh (21%), Mustafa Barghouti (9%), Salam Fayyad (7%), and
Saeb Erekat (4%).
- Significant improvement in public perception of
personal and family safety and security in the West Bank, standing today
at 58% compared to 43% one year ago, 35% two years ago, and 25% four years
ago (just few months before the last parliamentary elections in January 2006).
Findings also show some improvement in the perception of personal and
family safety and security in the Gaza Strip, standing today at 63%
compared to 54% one year ago, 49% two years ago, and 55% four years ago
(immediately after the Israeli withdrawal from the Gaza Strip and few
months before the last parliamentary elections).
- Continued decline in the perception that
corruption exists in PA institutions under the control of Abbas and Fayyad,
standing today at 68% compared to 72% one year ago, 80% two years ago, and
87% four years ago (few months before the last parliamentary elections).
- 60% say PA president Abbas loses his legitimacy
when his term ends next January if no new elections are organized and 30%
say he does not. Similarly, 59% say the Palestinian Legislative Council
loses its legitimacy next January when it too comes to the end of its
term.
- While an overwhelming majority (72%) opposes the
holding of separate elections in the West Bank alone and a larger majority
(79%) opposes holding separate elections in the Gaza Strip alone, and
while a majority of 58% believes that the Fateh-Hamas dialogue in Cairo
will fail, a majority of 54% opposes the holding of election next January
under the current status quo (assuming one is possible) with the presence
of two separate governments, one in the West Bank and one in the Gaza
Strip. 41% support such elections. In the meanwhile, a majority of 60%
opposes the postponement of elections for a year or more and 36% support
it.
- In addition to public confusion regarding
elections, the public has no confidence in the ability of elections to
contribute to national unification. 70% believe that both Fateh and Hamas,
or one of them, will reject the results of a fair and free elections if
these results favored its opponent. Only 22% say the two sides will accept
those results. However, the overwhelming majority of the respondents (83%)
say they themselves would accept the results of a fair and free election
even if they favored those whom they did not vote for.
- 53% say they are worried that they or a member of
their family would be hurt by other Palestinians, from Fateh or Hamas, and
46% say they are not worried. Respondents in the Gaza Strip and the West
Bank are equally worried. Three months ago, respondents in the Gaza Strip
were more worried than respondents in the West Bank (65% to 50%) which
means that the level of worry has dropped considerably in the Gaza Strip
and increased slightly in the West Bank.
- 49% agree and 45% disagree that the platform of a
National Unity Government should accept all agreements signed between the
PLO and Israel. These results are almost identical to those obtained three
months ago.
- About one third believes that unity between the
West Bank and the Gaza Strip will not be resumed and two entities will be
established while 12% say unity will resume soon and a majority of 53% says
unity will resume but only after a long time.
- In the aftermath of Fateh’s Sixth Congress, 39%
say Fateh will become stronger and more unified in the future and 22% say
it will become weaker and more fragmented and 34% say it will remain
unchanged. 40% say the newly elected Fateh leadership will be more able
than the previous leadership in achieving reconciliation with Hamas and
22% say it will be less able to do so. Similarly, 43% say the new
leadership will be more able than the pervious one to fight corruption
within Fateh while 21% thinks the opposite. But only 27% say the new
leadership will be more able to work toward ending occupation and 28% say
it will be less able than the pervious leadership.
- 9% of the public say they have been victims of
attacks or robbery by other Palestinians during the past year. Among
those, 40% say they have submitted a complaint to the police and security
services and 58% say they have not. 41% of those who did not submit a
complaint say the reason they did not submit one is that they do not trust
the police while 43% say the police can not do any thing to help them and
11% say they did not want to make the issue public. 26% of those who did
submit a complaint say they were satisfied with the police work in the
investigation to uncover the circumstances of the crime while 73% say they
were not satisfied. The percentage of those who submitted complaints is
higher in the West Bank (52%) than in the Gaza Strip (25%). Among those
who did not submit a complaint to the police, 57% in the Gaza Strip and
22% in the West Bank say the reason for this is the lack of trust in the
police. The levels of satisfaction with the performance of the police
among those who submitted a complaint stands at 21% in the Gaza Strip and
28% in the West Bank.
This poll was conducted with the support
of Konrad Adenauer Stiftung
– Ramallah.